The usual advice says winter is the discount season. You list in the cold, buyers know you're motivated, and you take less. Last winter in Johnson County didn't play out that way. The county's median sale price in December 2025 was $467,000. That's about the same as April 2026's $468,200, and higher than the $452,500 median this past October.
Winter didn't knock much off the price. It took away most of the competing listings, and in January it brought buyers back before spring sellers showed up. One thing is different this year. By the numbers, the slow season seems to have arrived early, in October. A winter listing this year rests less on what last December looked like and more on how ready you are when January comes.
Every figure below comes from the Kansas City Regional Association of REALTORS® monthly reports, which draw on Heartland MLS. They cover Johnson County, Kansas as a whole and don't break the county out by city.
Last winter, month by month
Here is Johnson County from November 2025 through May 2026. Each row comes from that month's Local Market Update.
| Month | Median sale price | % of original list price received | Days on market | Pending sales | Homes on the market |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nov 2025 | $458,650 | 98.9% | 35 | 594 | 1,522 |
| Dec 2025 | $467,000 | 98.3% | 44 | 430 | 1,299 |
| Jan 2026 | $445,000 | 97.4% | 53 | 577 | 1,330 |
| Feb 2026 | $460,000 | 98.9% | 46 | 681 | 1,402 |
| Mar 2026 | $470,000 | 100.3% | 39 | 887 | 1,388 |
| Apr 2026 | $468,200 | 100.9% | 37 | 988 | 1,546 |
| May 2026 | $485,000 | 101.3% | 30 | 1,057 | 1,568 |
From the coldest month to the busiest, the median moved by tens of thousands of dollars, not hundreds of thousands. May is the clear peak. December, February and April all came within a few thousand dollars of each other.
What a winter seller gave up
Two things got worse in winter: the share of the asking price sellers collected, and how long they waited. In the spring months of March through May 2026, Johnson County sellers typically got slightly more than their original list price, between 100.3% and 101.3%. In December and January that fell to 98.3% and 97.4%. On a home listed at $467,000, that three-point difference comes to roughly $14,000. That's real money. It's also a long way from the steep winter discount people tend to picture.
The wait cost more than the price did. Homes that sold in January 2026 spent 53 days on the market, against 30 for homes that sold in May. If you're already under contract on your next home, or carrying two mortgages, three extra weeks matter more than a percentage point.
Johnson County also holds its price through winter better than the wider metro does. Across the 19-county region the association tracks, existing homes got 95.2% of original list price in December 2025 and 95.1% in January 2026. That's two to three points below Johnson County in the same months. When you read a regional headline about a winter slump, keep in mind that the metro average includes markets that soften much more than this county does.
The competition dropped off faster than the buyers
The real advantage of a winter listing shows up in the inventory column. Johnson County had 1,810 homes on the market in October 2025 and 1,299 in December 2025, about 28% fewer in two months. A December listing simply had fewer homes to be compared against.
Then January came. Pending sales, meaning homes that went under contract that month, jumped from 430 in December to 577 in January and 681 in February. Over the same stretch, inventory barely moved: 1,299, then 1,330, then 1,402. Buyers came back before most spring sellers did.
You can see this by comparing contracts to listings. In December 2025, about 33 homes went under contract for every 100 on the market. In January it was about 43, and in February about 49. By March and April it was around 64, but by then sellers were listing in larger numbers too. Last winter, buyers came back faster than new competition from early January through February, after the holidays and before the spring listing wave.
This October already looked like last December
Here's what's different this year. In October 2026, Johnson County had 630 pending sales against 1,849 homes on the market. That's about 34 contracts per 100 listings. In October 2025 the figure was about 43, and in December 2025 about 33. On that measure, this October looked a lot like last December.
The year-over-year numbers for October 2026 show the same thing. Pending sales fell 19.6% from October 2025, closed sales fell 14.4% to 736, and the median slipped 2.7% to $452,500. Inventory rose slightly, 2.2%, to 1,849 homes. Across the metro, existing-home pending sales fell 19.5% over the same period.
Borrowing costs are a big part of this. Freddie Mac's weekly survey put the 30-year fixed rate at an average of 7.11% for the week ending November 12, 2026. A year earlier it was 6.24%. That November 12 reading was also the fourth weekly decline in a row and the lowest in seven weeks. Last winter's pattern took shape with rates near 6.2%. This winter starts with them near 7.1%, so the buyers who come back in January will be shopping at a different monthly payment.
Some of the county's strength hasn't changed. Even in this slow October, Johnson County sellers got 99.1% of original list price, the same as October 2025. Homes sold in 34 days, two days faster than a year earlier. Through the first ten months of 2026, the county had 8,199 closed sales, up 4.5% from the same period in 2025, and a year-to-date median of $475,000, up 1.3%. Fewer buyers signed contracts this fall, but homes that were priced right still sold close to their list price.
What this means for a winter listing decision
Taken together, this year's slow season seems to have started earlier than last year's. The January window that helped sellers last winter matters even more now. In December you're competing with the smallest pool of listings in the county. In January and February, contracts pick up faster than new listings do. Homes listed in March and April sell into the busiest stretch of the year, but against more competition. Last winter, those spring sellers collected about two to three more points of list price than the December and January sellers did.
There are practical takeaways. A home that hits the market in early January, already photographed, repaired and priced, meets the returning buyers before the spring wave. Plan the work backward from that date, starting in late November and December. Our step-by-step listing timeline lays out that sequence, and what it really costs to sell covers the prep budget. Pricing needs more care this winter, too. Last January's 97.4% of list happened in a stronger contract market than this October's, so a price set off last spring's numbers will probably sit on the market. Countywide medians also blend very different parts of the county, as we covered in why Johnson County's median home price won't tell you what houses actually cost. Your price should come from the homes that sold near you, not the county figure.
Mortgage rates move every week, and your own costs depend on your loan, your equity and your timing. This post is general market information, not financial or tax advice, so please confirm your situation with your lender or tax professional.
A few questions sellers ask this time of year
Does a December sale really bring less than an April sale in Johnson County? Last year it barely did. The December 2025 median was $467,000 and the April 2026 median was $468,200. Where the two months differed was the share of list price received and the days on market, so the gap showed up in negotiating room and time rather than in the median.
Is waiting until May the safest bet? May 2026 had the highest median in the table, $485,000, and the fastest sales, 30 days. It also had 1,568 homes on the market, about 270 more than December. Spring 2027 will play out on its own terms, and it will depend partly on where rates sit by then.
Are these numbers specific to Overland Park? No. The association publishes them for Johnson County as a whole, with no city breakdown. Your street's numbers can run higher or lower than the county's.
If you're weighing a January listing against waiting for spring, The Johns Family Team can price your home against the sales around you, not the county median, and build the prep calendar back from the date you choose. Start with a free home valuation, and we'll walk you through how your home would compare to the competition in December, January and April.